Years ago, having learned my craft at BBC Radio Cumbria and then at Red Rose, I was known as something of an editing wizard. Armed with nothing more than a pointed chinagraph, a keen ear, fast hands and an appreciation of editing techniques, I could turn a shambolic interview into something of a polished product. Miles of 1/4 inch tape around my neck, a good memory of where bits of tape went and a love of the job itself was all that was required. In fact, one of my first tasks was to get bits of old tape from half used spools and edit them together into larger spools so that it could be re-used some time in the future. God help you if you got the tape the wrong way round! Exciting times back then was when a magnetic bulk eraser was purchased and you could wipe loads of stuff at once, sometimes even your digital watch. As life progressed, I lost the knack of showing people how to edit but I missed this simple pleasure. It gave me a strange sense of peace and in those days there were no mobile phones to distract your attention.
Last week I asked my son Scott, who produces Hirsty's daily dose at Capital FM Yorkshire, to show me how to edit digitally. What a farce. I thought this was supposed to speed things up. Instead, people spend hours on the smallest detail, I am convinced they don't know when done is done. The result is that it can take twice as long to do anything and I have come to the conclusion that editing digitally is really lazy editing in reality. This is not progress, anyone can do it. I wonder if people prepare aswell because they can usually fix things in the edit? I can recall when you did the most you could do, as well as you could do it, the first time around and editing, while possible, was often regarded as a personal failure. I am convinced that the skill of the editor was higher in the past. In those days, your most valued gift was a stop watch, you had to count the time to when you started the music beneath the words so that you didn't crash the vocals, or any key production segment. Today, you cut this, flick that, swap from one bit to the other, speed it up and change so much that it looks slightly too easy for those who like to reflect on the 'good old days' when a razor blade was a deadly weapen. It was your light-saber and it could slice you to bits. God knows how the 'health and safety officer' today would have dealt with this!
Look at that picture above. Some see a tape machine, I see pure joy, hours of sex. A past love, a cherished memory. Granted, on large productions digital may have its benefits, but I would bet that even today, I could more than match anyone for speed and accuracy with my Revox verses one of these digital editing computers with their tiny buttons and hidden effects. I could edit faster, smarter and get the job done in half the time.
Tech ops, producers... jeezus. you don't know you're born. You just don't cut it.
PS. I also liked those big jingle cart machines with enormous buttons. They worked every time unlike the 'next' button... Ah, the good old days. What do you miss?
Above tongue firmly in cheek of course.
Above tongue firmly in cheek of course.
It's what comes out of the radio that matters, not how it's produced.
ReplyDeleteBut, yes, digital editing can be a huge time-sink. Surely it's better practise to get a good rough-mix assembled and then go back and sweat over the details? Then you can manage your time more efficiently and know that the end of your piece is at least sort-of finished.
The hardest part of digital production is knowing when you've finished, and finding that point where further tweaks aren't really making your work better.
If you're missing carts have a go with the Radio 1 cart player: http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio1/established1967/feature/cartplayer.shtml
I think you're dead right about the 'when it's done, it's done' bit. Almost like you've got too many options - occasionally I'll just have a glance through my pro-tools plug-ins and see just what you could be doing... and how... and then after a while get very lost indeed...
ReplyDelete"What do you miss?"
ReplyDeleteDangerous question John! I would do 100 but to remain sane here is 'My top 10':
I Miss:
1. the flexibility of choosing 3 jingles on cart in a row 5 seconds before the Pointer Sisters ends to PERFECTLY go into Buggles
2. hearing an ILR news bulletin with no damn ADVERT before during or immediately after it
3. theme tunes; always soo right to distinguish the personality, and ever since Johnny Walker played Duane Eddy's 'Because they're young' from 1965 onwards
4. handing over the a WARM live presenter rather than opting into LONDON output
5. handing over the a WARM live presenter rather than opting into a voice-tracked show
6. breakfast shows with one STRONG voiced, inventive dj, rather than the 'crew' with a yappy Essex-style 'girl' chipping in EVERY link
7. being told that 34% weekly reach is 'good' but we still need to 'improve..'
8. sitting in the studio for a James Whale phone-in on Metro until 2am as he was SO good I just had to watch listen and LEARN even though I had to be on-air that day at 9am
9. spending all Wednesday meeting the record reps with up to 100 new (vinyl) singles..
10. spending all Thursday creating a great LOCAL playlist that 'worked' just for my small part of England..
11. spending 5 days sat in the studio at JAM Dallas watching the most talented people in the jingle world create PERFECT jingles that to me still 'sell' that radio station namee perfectly even though it's now been 'thrown out'...
Oops that's 11....
Len
Brilliant Len. laughed so much at that. I agree in particular with 7, 9 and 11 especially. I also miss being handed the warm seat from the previous presenter and being told it was not his fault it was smelly
DeleteThank you kindly (Sir) John
Delete(I hear they have a spare one to allocate....)
The 'A' in central Portugal
Razor blades, editing blocks, chinagraph pencils and splicing tape - I remember them well!
ReplyDeleteAs a young TO at LBC/IRN in the mid-70s you had to be an 'editing wizard' - especially on a busy news day when you could be topping-and-tailing a pre-rec piece while the presenter was reading the cue (and waiting for a 'thumbs-up').
Mind you, can you imagine dealing with the inevitable pages of a Health & Safety risk assessment you would need to go through in order to do it like that today?
Let's also not forget the inherent dangers of working with reels of tape spinning at high speed without any safety guards or covers. Trying to stop a metal reel (or even a plastic one) by hand is not advised!